A New York State of Mind
The Washington Post
July 26, 1995
I NEVER really understood fairy tales. Even as a child, I knew that wolves and princes were not what they appeared to be: Their true meaning was always hidden, veiled, just beyond my grasp. But now, curled up on a window seat in a white room filled with wicker furniture, I am finally getting the straight scoop on the symbolism of stories.
Chautauqua, N.Y., the little town that time forgot, is that kind of place — where adults can listen to stories in the middle of the day, children can safely ride their bicycles in the middle of the street, and middle-aged executives can delve into a myriad of courses including marketing, mediation, modern Mexico, massage and music of the Middle Ages.
My husband came the same week, but in typical Chautauqua fashion chose a completely different track. He attended all the morning amphitheater lectures (which covered the thorniest issues of biomedical ethics), and for light fare he took a class on the development of the American economy and a philosophy seminar focusing on modern morality.
Our 7-year-old son, meanwhile, was enrolled in the Boys’ and Girls’ Club, where he went swimming and canoeing, played team sports and created some beautiful crafts projects. None of us found time to attend the poetry readings, piano recitals, book discussion groups, writing workshops, nature walks or other activities that round out a Chautauqua day.
Our week began with a Saturday night performance of “A Prairie Home Companion” with Garrison Keillor. Most of the audience was acutely aware of the parallels between Chautauqua-on-the-Lake and Lake Wobegon, so when Keillor stepped onto the Amphitheater stage the wooden structure literally shuddered from the sheer kinetic energy of recognition.
True, Chautauqua was founded by Methodist ministers rather than Lutherans, and people here are avid gardeners rather than farmers. But these are minor details. Chautauqua, like Keillor’s fictionalized home town, is fiercely loved by its residents, many of whom have been coming here for generations. Conversation is still a major form of recreation, and a great value is placed upon tolerance. All the children here are safe, all the men are good listeners, and all the women are above average.
Chautauqua started in 1874 as a summer institute for Sunday school teachers, but was soon flooded by ordinary families hungry for further learning. This was the Progressive era, when a middle class was emerging, but few could afford a college education. The modern concept of adult education had not yet been invented, nor had radio or television.
The camp by Lake Chautauqua, which began as a two-week tent affair, had tapped into a hole in the nation’s soul: It was soon attracting hundreds of families. In fact, quicker than you can say Xerox, “chautauqua” had become a generic term for both permanent and tent assemblies that sprang up across the country. (Our own Glen Echo Park was originally developed as a chautauqua site.) By the early 1920s, it is estimated that one out of every three Americans attended a chautauqua.
As might be imagined, the town is proud of its traditions, and some modern contraptions are unabashedly banned. Horseless carriages, for example. Guests may drive in to load and unload their belongings, but then the cars are exiled to parking lots just outside the grounds. Without cars, the streets are full of people and strollers and tricycles.
Since Chautauqua is a compact town, one can walk from one end to the other in 15 minutes. But like Little Red Riding Hood, I had a tendency to get distracted: I would take in the impromptu performances of street musicians, watch boys lazily launch wooden airplanes across Bestor Plaza, and talk to artists whose bright palettes revealed all the joy that is hidden in ordinary life.
And then, more often than not, I would run into someone I met at last night’s performance, or at one of my classes. So I would stop and talk, and then one of our teachers might spot us from a nearby porch, and invite us in for tea and further discussion.
Chautauqua, which has been designated as a National Historic Landmark, has its feet firmly planted in the turn-of-the-century. Strangers regularly greet and smile at each other on the street. The town’s architecture plays a large role in this: There are about 600 original Victorian buildings, and about 1,200 porches. We are talking active porches here, full of wicker furniture, cut flowers and people.
It is the porches, I think, that really define Chautauqua. People with porches are too busy to watch television. (I am told there are televisions here, but I have never actually seen one.) You can sit on a porch all day here and never get bored. There is a constant parade of people, and without the roar of traffic, conversations carry well.
You can hear a dozen reviews of the lecture that just ended, or a heated critique of last night’s violin solo. If you pick the right guest house, you can even hear the guest speaker from your rocking chair, since most of the lecture halls are open-air.
All these porches inevitably create a sense of community. If you have school-age children, you can allow them to roam the grounds with their new-found friends and feel confident that they will return unharmed. Chautauqua is a place where people routinely leave their doors unlocked, their bikes unchained and their minds open.
Maybe that’s why it’s easy to understand stories and metaphors here. It suddenly becomes clear how the outer world reflects the inner world. You begin to intuit the meaning of those dark and threatening fairy-tale forests, and you realize that to get out of the woods it is essential to go on a journey.
For my family, that journey begins in Chautauqua.
By Daphne White, Washington Post